As a former Deputy Head Teacher
in a large Scottish secondary school, I was occasionally called upon to deal
with pupil indiscipline. This sometimes involved interviewing a number of
pupils in an attempt to get at the truth following an incident. It was often
the case that the ‘interviewees’ were invariably the ‘usual suspects’ when it
came to challenging behaviour. Their stock initial response when questioned
was, “it wisnae me”. I often wondered if that was the family motto of some of
my more regular ‘interviewees’!
While most pupils were
honest and truthful most of the time, a small minority who struggled with
issues of behaviour were challenged by an inability to truthfully account for
their behavioural failures. Some feared the consequences of their behaviour:
exclusion from school and parental involvement, while other more culturally deprived youngsters were simply unable to be truthful
with ‘the authorities’.
Recently reflecting on this
aspect of my career, I was amused to read that researchers at Harvard University
in the USA have found that our ability to tell the truth is linked to individual
self control. Apparently when this is weakened through tiredness we are more
likely to lie!
According to journalist
Fiona MacRae, writing in The Mail Online: ‘The Harvard University study said
the more fundamentally honest someone is, the more likely they are to succumb
to the 'morning morality effect'.
Through a series of three
experiments the Harvard researchers found that: ‘people are vulnerable to a
gradual depletion of self-regulatory processes as a result of unremarkable
daily activities. This depletion can, in turn, lead them to act in ethically
questionable ways.
Unfortunately, it might be
that the most honest people are most susceptible to the negative consequences associated
with the morning morality effect. In other words, our findings suggest that the
mere time of day can lead to a systematic failure of good people to act
morally.’
Interesting though the
research is, I do not as a born again Christian, accept that it tells the whole
story. For me, the Bible gives a much clearer and simpler explanation to the
human inability to tell the truth all the time, and it’s all down to sin.
The Bible describes sin as
the breaking, or transgression, of God's law. It is defined in the Old
Testament as disobedience or rebellion against God. The original translation
means "to miss the mark" of God's standard of righteousness.
Now here’s the good news for
every human being: “If we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the
truth is not in us. If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive
us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.”